ServicenavigationHauptnavigationTrailKarteikarten


Forschungsstelle
BLV
Projektnummer
1.08.16
Projekttitel
Entwicklung und Evaluation eines Modells für die risiko-basierte Betriebsauswahl zum Nachweis der Seuchenfreiheit
Projekttitel Englisch
Development and evaluation of a model for risk-based herd sampling to substantiate freedom from disease

Texte zu diesem Projekt

 DeutschFranzösischItalienischEnglisch
Schlüsselwörter
-
-
-
Anzeigen
Kurzbeschreibung
Anzeigen
-
-
Anzeigen
Projektziele
-
-
-
Anzeigen
Umsetzung und Anwendungen
Anzeigen
-
-
Anzeigen
Publikationen / Ergebnisse
-
-
-
Anzeigen

Erfasste Texte


KategorieText
Schlüsselwörter
(Englisch)

Risk-based herd sampling, targeted sampling, freedom from disease, IBR, EBL, Switzerland, quantitative model.

Kurzbeschreibung
(Deutsch)

Im Rahmen dieses Projektes wird ein neuer, risikobasierter Ansatz für die Durchführung von Stichproben zum Nachweis der Seuchenfreiheit erarbeitet.

Das Modell wird für die beiden Krankheiten IBR (infektiöse bovine Rhinotracheitis) und EBL (enzootische bovine Leukose) entwickelt. Dafür wird für diese Krankheiten eine epidemiologische Analyse mit Identifizierung und Gewichtung von relevanten Risikofaktoren vorgenommen. Anschliessend wird ein quantitatives Modell auf der Basis des „stochastic scenario tree model“ erarbeitet. Der letzte Schritt im Projekt besteht im Erstellen einer Kosten-Nutzen-Analyse für den risikobasierten Ansatz der Stichprobenerhebung.

Das Ergebnis des Projektes könnte eine Grundlage für neue, kostengünstigere Überwachungsstrategien in der Schweiz darstellen.

Kurzbeschreibung
(Englisch)

Documented freedom from disease is the basis for international free trade of animals and animal products. It requires reliable information on the actual disease situation in a well-defined animal population. The implementation of surveys at regular intervals is an effective and often prescribed tool to gain the required information. But such surveys are very costly and conflict the decreasing resources in veterinary service. Therefore, an international requirement exists to develop new scientific methods providing the opportunity to decrease surveillance costs without jeopardizing the quality of the statement.

In Switzerland, surveys are conducted annually for the documentation of freedom from IBR, EBL, Brucella melitensis, Aujeszky’s disease and PRRS. Currently, the herds that have to be sampled are extracted randomly from the AGIS or TVD database. But random sampling of herds does not take into account uneven distribution of disease risk. In fact, some herds have higher probability for infection than others due to different risk factors, e.g. excessive animal movement. Testing those high-risk strata is assumed to offer a higher potential of detecting disease if it would be present. Conversely, if herds are selected randomly for a survey, this sampling does not offer the highest probability of detecting disease. Therefore, the sampling should be conducted in herds with the highest risk for infection and therefore the highest probability of detecting disease to optimize the information content of a survey. Consequently, we assume that the necessary sample size for such a targeted surveillance will be smaller than for random sampling. This will reduce the costs of the regular surveys to document freedom from disease.

In this project, the application of targeted surveillance shall be worked out for the case studies of infectious bovine rhinotracheitis (IBR) and enzootic bovine leucosis (EBL) in Swiss cattle population. A quantitative model will be developed providing the number of required herds out of a specific high-risk stratum for the documentation of freedom from disease for a certain level of confidence and the optimal combination of herds from different risk strata will be tested.

The results of this project and the developed model will provide the Swiss veterinary service with a cost-efficient surveillance tool for future surveillance strategies.

Projektziele
(Englisch)

The economization of surveillance methods for documenting freedom from disease is an important international research topic. Resources of veterinary services for disease surveillance are more and more constraint, but the spread of emerging infectious diseases due to globalization and climate change represents an increasing challenge. TS with testing selected high-risk population strata is a promising approach for a reliable but cost-efficient surveillance strategy. But to our knowledge, it has not been worked out and tested thoroughly within the scope of national surveillance programs.

In this project, the application of TS shall be worked out for infectious bovine rhinotracheitis (IBR) and enzootic bovine leucosis (EBL) in Swiss cattle population. An epidemiological analysis for those case studies IBR and EBL, respectively, will be conducted to figure out all risk factors for infection. According to the identified risk factors, the cattle population, i.e. cattle herds in Switzerland will be stratified and split up into different risk strata. A scoring system to weight the importance of each risk factor for infection has to be worked out in parallel. This scoring system will allow to quantify the information yield we gain by testing a herd having a higher risk for infection compared to a herd with lower risk for infection.

Based on the stratification of the cattle population and the developed scoring system, a new generic quantitative model will be developed based on the stochastic scenario tree model of Hadorn & Stärk (submitted). The developed model shall provide the number of required herds for the documentation of freedom from IBR and EBL, respectively, given that the sampling is conducted exclusively in the appropriate high-risk strata.

Scenarios of different arrangements between TS and RS will be created. The relative effectiveness of these scenarios in detection of disease will be evaluated by mathematical modeling (VenSim®) and the calculation of their potential cost-effectiveness. With the population model, different epidemics will be simulated stochastically, and the detection power of the scenarios will be measured. The theIn a cost-benefit analysis, the expected benefit of TS will be quantified.

The annual surveys in Swiss cattle population for IBR and EBL are conducted in one sampling round. For this reason, it would be of interest to know if the surveys can be conducted on the same farms. Therefore, as a last step in the project, the population strata and the resulting quantitative model for IBR and EBL will be compared. If common risk factors exist for both diseases and if the high-risk strata for both diseases are identical, a general model can be developed including the parameters for IBR as well as EBL. In this case, the sampling procedure will be the same for both diseases. In case that TS for IBR and EBL seems to be beneficial compared to RS, TS will be implemented in the annual national survey in Switzerland.

Umsetzung und Anwendungen
(Deutsch)
31.05.2007: Umsetzung: Kosteneffizientere Stichprobenplanung (Selektionssitzung 2007/mvo)
Umsetzung und Anwendungen
(Englisch)

The increasing duties and responsibilities of veterinary service conflict with the decreasing availability of resources for animal disease surveillance. Therefore, surveys should be as efficient as possible and gain maximum information content using a minimum amount of resources.

With this project, the current survey design will be refined in such a way that the sampling will be conducted exclusively in high risk strata of the population. With this targeted sampling, resources are focused on sub-strata of the population where the probability is highest to find the disease given the disease is present at a certain design prevalence. Consequently, sample sizes can be reduced without compromising the level of confidence for documenting freedom from disease. We expect that the cost-benefit ratio between such targeted surveys and their information content will be optimized.

If TS seems to be applicable for IBR and EBL, respectively, we plan to implement TS in the future annual surveys for the documentation of freedom from those two diseases in Switzerland.

The results of this project and the quantitative model will be applicable to different animal diseases and different populations and animal species. Therefore, this project will serve as a basis for future evaluation of conducting TS instead of RS in the annual surveys for the documentation of freedom from Brucella melitensis, Aujeszky’s disease and PRRS. This will provide the Swiss veterinary service with a modern and cost-saving surveillance tool for the documentation of freedom from disease.

UMS 2011: 
Projektergebnisse sind bereits in Stichprobenplanung eingeflossen. Status: erledigt. (mvo)

Publikationen / Ergebnisse
(Englisch)

Blickenstorfer S., Schwermer H., Engels M., Reist M., Hadorn D. (2010) „Entwicklung und Evaluation eines Modells für die risikobasierte Betriebsauswahl zum Nachweis der Seuchenfreiheit“. Oral presentation at the DVG conference in Leipzig.

Blickenstorfer S. (2010) „Entwicklung und Evaluation eines Modells für die gezielte risikobasierte Betriebsauswahl zum Nachweis der Seuchenfreiheit“. Doctoral thesis, Faculty of Veterinary Medecine, University of Berne.

Blickenstorfer S., Schwermer H., Engels M., Reist M., Doherr M., Hadorn D. Using scenario tree modelling for targeted herd sampling to substantiate freedom from disease. BMC Veterinary Research 2011, 7:49.

 

Blickenstorfer, S.; Schwermer, H.; Engels, M.; Reist, M.; Doherr, M.; Hadorn, D. (2011) „Using scenario tree modelling for targeted herd sampling to substantiate freedom from disease”. BMC Veterinary Research, 7:49.

 

 

 

Zugehörige Dokumente